Playoff history
2003
| #8 Western Kentucky WarHogs (77) | #1 East Coast SubVets (70) |
| #7 West Kentucky Rams (100) | #2 Kalamazoo Wings (97) |
| #3 Louisville Lumber (80) | #6 Ga St Prison Mean Machine (68) |
| #4 Richmond nWo Outsiders (99) | #5 Poland Pirates (73) |
Final Four |
|
| #3 Louisville Lumber (81) | #8 Western Kentucky WarHogs (80) |
| #4 Richmond nWo Outsiders (95) | #7 West Kentucky Rams (68) |
Championship Game - Bluegrass Bowl I |
|
| #4 Richmond nWo Outsiders (88) | #3 Louisville Lumber (73) |
2004
| #1 Ga St Prison Mean Machine (108) | #8 Louisa Lumber (46) |
| #7 Huggs Thuggs (140) | #2 Auxier RiverRats (97) |
| #3 Richmond nWo Outsiders (79) | #6 Florence Fighters (23) |
| #4 Wabash SubVets (92) | #5 West Kentucky Rams(64) |
Final Four |
|
| #1 Ga St Prison Mean Machine (103) | #7 Kentucky Blackcats (98) |
| #4 Wabash SubVets (105) | #3 Richmond nWo Outsiders (80) |
Championship Game - Bluegrass Bowl II |
|
| #1 Ga St Prison Mean Machine (106) | #4 Wabash SubVets (98) |
2005
| #8 Auxier RiverRats (112) | #1 Grayson County Swamptrash (79) |
| #2 Louisville Legends (72) | #7 Ga. St. Prison Mean Machine (61) |
| #3 Wabash SubVets (85) | #6 Huggs Thuggs (44) |
| #4 Brush Creek Rusty Ankles (103) | #5 West Kentucky Rams (68) |
Final Four |
|
| #8 Auxier RiverRats (95) | #2 Louisville Legends (72) |
| #3 Wabash SubVets (70) | #4 Brush Creek Rusty Ankles (58) |
Championship Game - Bluegrass Bowl III |
|
| #8 Auxier RiverRats (122) | #3 Wabash SubVets (96) |
2006
| #8 Western Kentucky WarHogs (84) | #1 Kalamazoo Wings (48) |
| #2 Auxier RiverRats (90) | #7 Brush Creek Rusty Ankles (88) |
| #6 Ga. St. Prison Mean Machine (94) | #3 Louisville Legends (55) |
| #5 Paintsville Pythons (99) | #4 Sitka Stars (88) |
Final Four |
|
| #2 Auxier RiverRats (54) | #8 Western Kentucky WarHogs (42) |
| #6 Ga. St. Prison Mean Machine (83) | #5 Paintsville Pythons (71) |
Championship Game - Bluegrass Bowl IV |
|
| #6 Ga. St. Prison Mean Machine (88) | #2 Auxier RiverRats (86) |
2007
| #1 Louisville Legends (118) | #8 Western Kentucky Rams (83) |
| #2 Kalamazoo Wings (103) | #7 Southern KY SubVets (81) |
| #3 Richmond nWo Outsiders (86) | #6 East End Evolution (74) |
| #5 Huggs Thuggs (98) | #4 Louisa Lumber (84) |
Final Four |
|
| #1 Louisville Legends (82) | #5 Huggs Thuggs (69) |
| #2 Kalamazoo Wings (67) | #3 Richmond nWo Outsiders (58) |
Championship Game - Bluegrass Bowl V |
|
| #1 Louisville Legends (89) | #2 Kalamazoo Wings (85) |